Washington Redskins

Should the Knicks match offer for Jeremy Lin?


Should the Knicks match offer for Jeremy Lin?

From Comcast SportsNet
Back in February, Jeremy Lin was Kobe Bryant's equal on the court and at the souvenir stand during a mesmerizing period that NBA commissioner David Stern said he had "never quite seen anything like." There was no way the New York Knicks were letting Lin get away back then, when he was the biggest thing in the basketball. Things are different now. Lin no longer plays for a coach whose offense seems designed for him. He's coming off knee surgery and would come at a monstrous cost -- thanks to an offer sheet from the Houston Rockets he signed -- even for one of the league's richest teams. So what once would have been an easy answer now creates so many questions. Do the Knicks want Lin back? Does Lin want to go back? When will it be resolved? The last one should be resolved the easiest. Teams have three days to match an offer sheet for their restricted free agents, so the Rockets believe the clock expires late Tuesday. Except the Knicks have never confirmed if they received the offer sheet from the Rockets on Saturday, so it's possible they have a different deadline in mind, which could even lead to some kind of dispute or protest. The contract is for three years and about 25 million, an enormous figure for someone who has made 25 starts. After paying Lin about 5 million per year the first two seasons, it balloons to nearly 15 million in the final year but would cost the Knicks more than twice that in luxury tax payments under the harsher penalties in the new collective bargaining agreement. The terms of the original offer Lin had agreed to were for four years and about 28 million, creating speculation that he went back to the Rockets and asked for something that would be tougher for the Knicks to match. A number of fans want them to do it anyway, more than 5,000 signing an online petition at Change.org asking the Knicks to keep him. Team officials, who repeatedly said they intended to keep Lin before he signed the offer, won't comment on their plans now. "I hope we get it done, man. I hope we can get it done," Knicks forward Carmelo Anthony said. "I would love to see him back, honestly, I would definitely love to see him back. But knowing the business of basketball, it's kind of a tough situation, kind of for both parties. With Jeremy, I know he definitely would want to be back in New York, and with the team, (owner James) Dolan definitely wants him back." Anthony had called the Rockets' offer a "ridiculous contract" on Sunday and said he wasn't surprised by the backlash that followed. "It was ridiculous for them to do what they did, as far as throwing that out there and making it tough on us to sign him back," Anthony said. Maybe the Knicks could have avoided this by making Lin an offer right away. Instead they let him find one elsewhere first, which is what many teams do with restricted free agents. Given his popularity in New York and all the opportunities that affords, it's difficult to imagine he'd want to sabotage his chances of returning. Yet maybe he doesn't see the same potential for himself under Mike Woodson as he showed in Mike D'Antoni's pick-and-roll offense. Or perhaps he's one of the many who sees the futility of the Anthony-Amare Stoudemire pairing and doesn't want the burden of being the point guard charged with making it work. And maybe the Knicks don't believe he is, anyway. They made a veteran point guard a top priority in free agency, missing out on Steve Nash but signing Jason Kidd. Then they agreed to a sign-and-trade with Portland to bring back Raymond Felton to New York in a deal that was completed on Monday. None brings the marketing potential of Lin, whose story of undrafted Harvard Universty graduate to unexpected NBA star was a hit around the world. (How many other players went into free agency with "Time" magazine list of top 100 most influential people on their resume?) That gives Houston plenty of reason to want him back. The NBA's first American-born player of Chinese or Taiwanese descent would continue to grow the popularity the Rockets already enjoy in Asia thanks to their retired star, Yao Ming. The Rockets had Lin on their roster during the preseason before waiving him, with two point guards ahead of him on the depth chart and an open roster spot needed to add a big man. It wasn't long before they wished they'd done differently, general manager Daryl Morey writing on Twitter during Lin's dazzling span, when he averaged 24.6 points and 9.2 assists in 10 games from Feb. 4-20, that cutting Lin was a mistake. Now it's up to the Knicks. Keep Linsanity where it was born or risk the same regret.

Quick Links

Need to Know: Grading the Redskins free agent pickups after training camp

Need to Know: Grading the Redskins free agent pickups after training camp

Here is what you need to know on this Thursday, August 17, 16 days before the Washington Redskins cut their roster to 53 on September 2.


The Redskins last played a game 228 days ago; they will open the 2017 season against the Eagles at FedEx Field in 24 days.

Today’s schedule: Practice 11:55 1.m.; Jay Gruden news conference and player availability after practice, approx. 2 p.m.

Days until:

—Preseason vs. Packers at FedEx Field (8/19) 2
—Redskins @ Rams (9/17) 31
—Sunday night Raiders @ Redskins (9/24) 38

Grading the Redskins’ free agents

Yesterday, colleague JP Finlay posted his grades on the Redskins’ rookies based on how they have performed since training camp started. Here, I’m going to do the same thing with the unrestricted free agents the Redskins signed this offseason.

ILB Zach Brown, B+—The only Pro Bowl player among the free agents signed, Brown has taken some time to find his niche in the defense. While many fans lamented that he didn’t start against the Ravens, he got more playing time because he went in with the second unit. In 12 snaps he had two tackles, including one for a loss. His grade could well improve over the coming weeks.

ILB Chris Carter, C—He was signed eight days before they got the opportunity to snag Brown so he must fight his way off the bubble. The former Steeler, Bengal, Colt, and Raven has not done much to turn heads but, to be fair, he likely was thought of as more of a special teams signing. There isn’t much you can do to distinguish yourself there in practice. That is the way he will have to make the team.

RELATED: Have the Redskins found their starting nose tackle?

DE Terrell McClain, C—To be fair, it’s hard to judge the defensive line because of the way that Jim Tomsula rotates his players. I’d note a good play by McClain and then realize that it was against the third-string offense and a tackle who isn’t going to make the team. He got a quarterback hurry in 14 snaps against the Ravens. While he has had his moments, his play does not consistently pop.

DE Stacy McGee, C—As with McClain, how he performed in camp often was a function of who he was facing. He made a key mistake against the Ravens, lining up improperly and giving the Ravens the opportunity to turn a missed field goal into a touchdown. The former Raider played 15 snaps and did not show up on the stat sheet for anything other than the penalty. The Redskins should expect for the $9 million in contract guarantees they doled out to McGee.

WR Brian Quick, C—The ex-Ram was largely invisible in the offseason program but he became more productive as camp went on. Against the Ravens, he caught all three passes that were thrown to him and he will need to keep up that type of performance if he is going to beat out rookie Robert Davis for the last receiver roster spot.

MORE REDSKINS: Must-see photos from Redskins vs. Ravens

WR Terrelle Pryor, A—I don’t think there is a whole lot more to say about him that hasn’t already been said. Pryor has been standing out since the first day and things have gone up from there, thanks to his improving chemistry with Kirk Cousins.

S D.J. Swearinger, A—Even the most confident players can take a while to assume a leadership role when coming from a new team, especially at age 25 with a history of being with his fourth team in his fifth year in the NFL. Not Swearinger. He has embraced the role and has taken charge of the secondary, shouting encouragement to the defense, giving friendly taunts to the offense and taking young players aside to correct their mistakes.

NT Phil Taylor, B—Technically Taylor was not a UFA. He was not on a team at the end of the 2016 season so when he signed in January he was signed to a futures contract or, in the more common vernacular, as a “street” free agent. He has come back well after two years out of football. In 12 snaps against the Ravens, he was stout against the run and got a QB pressure.

Stay up to date on the Redskins. Rich Tandler covers the team 365 days a year. Like his Facebook page Facebook.com/TandlerCSN and follow him on Twitter @Rich_TandlerCSN.

Tandler on Twitter

In case you missed it

Quick Links

Ranking people the Redskins let go this offseason whom they could end up missing

USA Today Sports Images

Ranking people the Redskins let go this offseason whom they could end up missing

No NFL organization has transitioned or ever will transition from one season to the next while staying entirely intact. Not even the perfect Patriots keep every single player, coach and executive from the year before, as free agents must be let go and decision-makers are pushed out of the door for perceived better options.

The 2017 Redskins look much different than the 2016 Redskins, for example, who looked much different than the 2015 Redskins, and so on and so forth. But which of the people that Washington recently allowed to leave will they end up missing the most? Who are the guys that the team could seriously regret not making more of an effort to retain?

Let's rank some of the biggest names.

(Note: This list is solely made up of names that the Redskins chose to not bring back. Sean McVay, for example, was hired away from Washington and therefore isn't found below. Meanwhile, players like Duke Ihenacho and David Bruton, who were not re-signed, won't be listed because the Redskins won't exactly miss them)


6. Kedric Golston

With Golston no longer around, DeAngelo Hall presently holds the title of longest-tenured Redskin. And while the now-34-year-old Golston is coming off a severe hamstring injury and never was a major producer in terms of stats, his teammates constantly mentioned him as one of the strongest and most-respected figures in D.C., someone they could count on to set an example.

Of course, Washington needed to perform a major overhaul of their defensive line, and getting rid of the aging Golston was something that needed to happen. But dropping a player who had been with the 'Skins for a decade and who knew the Burgundy and Gold as well as anybody could end up having some smaller, unforeseen consequences, particularly off the field.

5. Ricky Jean Francois

Jean Francois had a similar reputation to Golston's — that of a leader on defense. He's only 30, however, meaning he should have much more left to contribute in his future than Golston, and the Redskins knew what they had in him, compared to newer defensive linemen who'll replace him such as Stacy McGee and Terrell McClain.

RJF is far from a stud, yes, but he played in all 32 games with Washington in his two seasons with the franchise and has established himself as a winner in the NFL. There's a decent chance the front office is eventually disappointed with its decision to not keep Jean Francois, who's now in Green Bay, over its recent additions.

4. Chris Baker

Baker is easily the most useful defender that the Redskins didn't re-sign this past offseason. He was open in his desire to stay, and the two sides did have some talks about a return, but ultimately, the Redskins didn't make much of an effort to make one happen. Now, Swaggy is in Tampa Bay.

In many other cities, Baker wouldn't have been the best D-lineman on the roster. But he certainly was while playing in the nation's capital the past few campaigns, and if Jim Tomsula's bunch has a repeat of the issues the unit had in 2016, many will point to the lack of pursuit for Baker as a mistake. He and Jonathan Allen would've formed a pretty nice duo, but now, guys like Allen, Matt Ioannidis and Anthony Lanier must grow up quickly in his absence.


3. Pierre Garçon

Garçon feels like the type of player that fans and coaches miss pretty soon after they see what life is like without him. He rarely made game-altering catches, but when it came to important third downs, fighting for some extra yards or setting the tone with his intensity, few in the league were more dependable than No. 88.

The 31-year-old is back with Kyle Shanahan in San Francisco, and the reason many aren't too worried about his departure is because of Josh Doctson, who should slide in and fill Garçon's role while hopefully becoming a more dynamic threat. Docston's health and capacity to adapt to the pro game is a large wild card, however, and Garçon was anything but with the Redskins.

2. Scot McCloughan

The only non-player to make this list, but deservedly so. The ex-GM had a hand in crucial moves like the drafting of Brandon Scherff and Jamison Crowder, the signings of Josh Norman, Will Blackmon, Mason Foster and more, and was vital when it came to pushing the organization back into a place where it was relevant.

Yet McCloughan is gone now, after having been fired in March. It could be difficult to truly quantify his loss, since it can't be measured in touchdowns or tackles, but odds are the Redskins will feel it at all levels.

1. DeSean Jackson

The first four ex-Redskins mentioned will likely be missed to some extent, but at least they have pretty clear successors. McCloughan and Jackson, though? Those are two talents that are very rare.

Jackson's speed transformed matchups in a matter of seconds; there'd be weeks where it'd look like the 'Skins had nothing going, and one 60-yard pass later, they'd be on their way to a victory. The attention he attracted also made Jordan Reed, Crowder and others more effective. And Kirk Cousins hasn't known what it's like to be a starter for a full year without Jackson on the outside for most of it.

Terrelle Pryor's had an excellent camp, and Crowder and Doctson are attractive targets, too. Unfortunately, none of them have an all-time skill like Jackson does, and while it would've been tough to match the Bucs' pricey offer for him, the Redskins may realize in a hurry that his ability was worth everything else he came with.